Skip to main content
Logo image

Section 4.6 Flow past an aerofoil

Subsection 4.6.1 Circle maps

Previously we used the method of images to construct flows past polygonal and straight boundaries.

Proof.

(i) if \(|z| > a\text{,}\) then \(|a^2/\overline{z}| < a\text{.}\) Therefore the argument of the second term of \(w\) is within the circle of radius \(|a|\) and by assumption \(f\) is not singular there.
(ii) On the circle itself, \(z = a\e^{\im\theta}\text{.}\) Then \(a^2/\overline{z} = a\e^{\im\theta} = z\text{.}\) Therefore, we have
\begin{equation*} w(z) = f(z) + \overline{f(z)} = 2 \Re[f(z)]. \end{equation*}
Therefore the complex potential is entirely real. It follows that \(\Im w = 0\) on \(|z| = a\text{,}\) establishing that the circle is streamline.
The above theorem then allows us to easily construct certain flows past circular cylinders. Here is an example.

Example 4.6.2. Uniform flow past a circular cylinder.

We begin with the complex potential given by \(f(z) = Uz\text{,}\) which corresponds to horizontal uniform flow. We then consider inserting a circular cylinder with boundary \(|z| = a\text{.}\) Clearly, \(f\) satisfies the requirements of the Circle Theorem since it is non-singular for all \(z\text{.}\) Thus, we can construct the following result
The streamlines of the flow, found by taking the imaginary part of the above, are shown in Figure 4.6.4.
Circle flow
Figure 4.6.4. Uniform flow past a circle
The next example will be studied during the problem class.

Example 4.6.5. Problem class example.

Previously, it was demonstrated, via (4.6.2) that uniform horizontal flow past a circle (circular cylinder) of radius \(a\) can be found via the complex potential function
\begin{equation} w(z) = Uz + \frac{Ua^2}{z}, \tag{4.6.3} \end{equation}
corresponding to uniform horizontal flow at infinity of speed \(U\text{.}\)
(a)
Confirm, by use of the streamfunction \(\psi\text{,}\) that the circle boundary is a streamline of the flow.
It will be useful to remind yourself that
\begin{equation} \cos\theta = \frac{\e^{\im\theta} + \e^{-\im\theta}}{2}. \tag{4.6.4} \end{equation}
Solution.
We set \(z = a\e^{\im\theta}\) into the streamfunction. This gives
\begin{equation*} \phi + \im \psi = U \left( \e^{\im \theta} + \e^{-\im\theta}\right) = 2U\cos\theta. \end{equation*}
Therefore \(\psi = \Im w = 0\) on the surface of the cylinder.
(b)
Derive the complex velocity, \(u - \im v\) and use it to show that on the surface of the cylinder, the velocity is given by
\begin{equation*} u - \im v = 2U \e^{\im (\pi/2 - \theta)} \sin\theta, \end{equation*}
where \(z = a\e^{\im\theta}\text{.}\)
It is helpful for you to remember that
\begin{equation} \sin\theta = \frac{\e^{\im\theta} - \e^{-\im\theta}}{2\im}.\tag{4.6.5} \end{equation}
Solution.
We need to take the derivative to obtain the complex velocity. So we have
\begin{equation*} w'(z) = u - \im v = U\left(1 - \frac{a^2}{z^2}\right). \end{equation*}
So again, substitution of \(z = a\e^{\im\theta}\) and simplifying gives
\begin{equation*} u - \im v = U \e^{-\im \theta}\left( \e^{\im\theta} - \e^{-\im\theta}\right) = 2U \e^{\im(\pi/2 - \theta)} \sin\theta. \end{equation*}
(c)
Conclude that on the surface of the cylinder, the maximum velocity is \(|\bu| = 2U\text{.}\) Where does this maximum velocity occur? Where do stagnation points in the flow (where the velocity is zero) occur?
Solution.
From the above, we clearly see that the magnitude is \(|u - \im v| = 2U\sin\theta\) so the maximum speed on the cylinder is \(2U\text{.}\) This value is obtained at the top and bottom with \(\theta = \pm \pi/2\text{.}\) The stagnation point is found where the speed is zero, and this is at the fore and aft points, \(\theta = \pi, 0\text{.}\)
(d)
Show that on the surface of the cylinder, the pressure force is given by
\begin{equation*} p = p_\infty + \frac{1}{2} \rho U^2(1 - 4\sin^2\theta), \end{equation*}
where \(p_\infty\) is a constant value.
Solution.
We know from Bernoulli’s equation, without gravity, that we have (Theorem 3.5.9):
\begin{equation*} \left(p + \frac{\rho}{2} |\bu|^2\right)_{\text{cylinder}} = \left(p_\infty + \frac{\rho}{2} U^2\right)_{\text{infinity}} \end{equation*}
where we have set the constant on the RHS of the formula to be \(p_\infty/\rho\text{,}\) setting a reference pressure. We now only need to substitute the speed on the cylinder, \(|\bu| = U(4\sin^2\theta)\text{,}\) giving
\begin{equation*} p = p_\infty + \frac{\rho}{2}U^2(1 - 4\sin^2\theta) \end{equation*}
as desired.
(e)
It is possible to add a line vortex to the interior of the circular cylinder, centred at \(z = 0\) by writing in addition to (4.6.3), an additional term:
\begin{equation*} w(z) = U \left(z + \frac{a^2}{z}\right) - \frac{\im\Gamma}{2\pi} \log z. \end{equation*}
Verify again that the above modification does not change the streamline properties of \(|z| = a\text{.}\)
Does the above flow satisfy the condition that the flow is of uniform speed \(U\) far upstream?
Solution.
The addition of the line vortex does not change the streamline patterns on the cylinder since it is a linear addition. Indeed, on the surface, we have from the addition:
\begin{equation*} -\frac{\im \Gamma}{2\pi} (\log a + \im \pi \theta) = -\frac{\Gamma}{2\pi} (-\pi \theta + \im \log a). \end{equation*}
Therefore the imaginary part is still a constant, and hence the boundary of the cylinder is still a streamline of the flow.
To verify that the upstream flow is not altered, we can take a derivative to obtain the complex velocity:
\begin{equation*} w'(z) = u - \im v = U\left(1 - \frac{a^2}{z^2}\right) - \frac{\im}{2\pi z}. \end{equation*}
So in the limit \(|z| \to \infty\text{,}\) we see indeed that the velocity is horizontal with speed \(U\text{.}\)
(f)
By studying the velocity of the flow with the rotation element, verify that the complex velocity on the surface is given by
\begin{equation*} u - \im v = \im \e^{-\im\theta}\left(2U \sin\theta - \frac{\Gamma}{2\pi a}\right). \end{equation*}
Conclude that a point on the cylinder that satisfies the equation
\begin{equation*} \sin\theta = \frac{\Gamma}{4\pi a U}, \end{equation*}
is a stagnation point of the flow.
Solution.
We had previously simplified the left terms in brackets:
\begin{equation*} u - \im v = 2U \im \e^{-\im\theta}\sin\theta - \frac{\Gamma\im}{2\pi a} \e^{-\im\theta} = \im \e^{-\im\theta} \left(2U \sin\theta - \frac{\Gamma}{2\pi a}\right). \end{equation*}
A stagnation point requires that \(|u - \im v| = 0\text{,}\) so setting the terms in brackets to zero implies
\begin{equation*} \sin\theta = \frac{\Gamma}{4\pi a U}, \end{equation*}
as desired.
(g)
(Not examinable) Use a computational tool to investigate the streamlines of the flow for \(\Gamma = 0, 2\pi aU, 4\pi a U, and 6\pi a U\text{.}\)
The fact that the stagnation point shifts, moving on the topside or bottomside of the circular cylinder, dependent on the value of \(\Gamma\) will result in an asymmetry in the pressure, causing net force on one side of the cylinder. This is related to the well-known Magnus effect, which is used by athletes to cause a ball’s trajectory to move from a straight path.
Solution.
The point of the previous exercise is to note that when \(\Gamma \neq 0\text{,}\) this shifts the location of the stagnation point. For example, if \(\Gamma = 4\pi a U\text{,}\) then the stagnation points are found at
\begin{equation*} \sin\theta = 1 \Longrightarrow \theta = \pi/2, \end{equation*}
i.e. the top of the cylinder.
Flow past a circular cylinder with vortex
Figure 4.6.6. Flow past a circular cylinder with interior line vortex of different strengths.

Subsection 4.6.2 The Joukowski map

We shall study the following mapping.

Definition 4.6.7.

The Joukowski transformation is the map
\begin{equation} z = G(\zeta) = \zeta + \frac{a^2}{\zeta}\tag{4.6.6} \end{equation}
where \(a > 0\) is a parameter. The mapping is conformal at all points except \(\zeta = 0\) (pole) and \(\zeta = \pm a\) where \(G'(\zeta) = 0\text{.}\)
Consider a circle in the \(\zeta\)-plane. Let \(\zeta = r\e^{\im\theta}\text{.}\) Then in the \(z\)-plane, this is mapped to
\begin{equation*} z = r\e^{\im\theta} + \frac{a^2}{r}\e^{-\im\theta} = \left(r + \frac{a^2}{r}\right)\cos\theta + \im \left(r - \frac{a^2}{r}\right)\sin\theta. \end{equation*}
Provided that \(r > a\text{,}\) this the equation of an ellipse with principle radii \(r + a^2/r\) and \(r - a^2/r\text{.}\) The orientation of circles is preserved, with an anticlockwise rotation in \(\zeta\) corresponding to anticlockwise in \(z\text{.}\) The exterior of the circle \(|\zeta| = r\) is mapped to the exterior of the ellipse in \(z\text{.}\)
In addition note that if \(r \to a\text{,}\) the ellipses tends to the line segment
\begin{equation*} S = \{ z = 2a\cos\theta \, | 0 \leq \theta \leq \pi\}, \end{equation*}
which then ranges from \(z = 2a\) for \(\theta = 0\) to \(z = -2a\) for \(\theta = \pi\text{.}\) As \(\theta\) further ranges in \([\pi, 2\pi)\text{,}\) this traverses the horizontal plate again. One can interpret it as traversing the top or the bottom side of the plate (a view strengthened from considering the limiting images). This is shown in Figure 4.6.8.
Joukowski map
Figure 4.6.8. The Joukowski transformation in (4.6.6) sends circles with radius \(r \geq 1\) to ellipses in the \(z-\)plane. In the limit \(r \to a^+\text{,}\) this approaches a horizontal plate of length \(4a\text{.}\)
If on the other hand, \(r < a\text{,}\) then we can verify that the mapping still produces ellipses, but now with principal radii \(r + a^2/r\) and \(a^2/r - r\text{.}\) The orientation is now reversed, with anticlockwise orientation in \(\zeta\) mapped to clockwise orientation. Therefore, it is the case that the interior of the discs with \(|\zeta| = r\) are mapped to the exterior of ellipses in \(z\text{.}\) Again, in the limit that \(r \to a^-\) the images approach a flat plate of length \(4a\) on the axis.
Joukowski map
Figure 4.6.9. The Joukowski transformation in (4.6.6) sends circles with radius \(r \leq 1\) to ellipses in the \(z-\)plane. As \(r \to \infty\text{,}\) these tend to infinitely large circles. The values here are \(r = 0.5, 0.6, 0.7, 0.8, 0.9, 1.\)
We can invert (4.6.6), and this gives
\begin{equation} \zeta = \frac{1}{2} \left(z \pm \sqrt{z^2 - 4a^2}\right) = \frac{1}{2} \left(z \pm \sqrt{z-2a}\sqrt{z + 2a}\right).\tag{4.6.7} \end{equation}
As noted in Subsection 1.2.3, we must take care to define the proper branch cut structure for the two branch points at \(z = \pm 2a\text{.}\)
As noted in the exercises of Exercises 1.3, if we let
\begin{equation*} z + 2a = r_1 \e^{\im \theta_1} \quad \text{and} \quad z - 2a = r_2 \e^{\im \theta_2}, \end{equation*}
and take \(\theta_1, \theta_2 \in [0, 2\pi)\text{,}\) this corresponds to a single branch cut between \(z = -2a\) and \(z = 2a\text{.}\) This branch cut choice is the most convenient since then it directly coincides with the central axis of the ellipse.
Once the proper branch structure has been chosen, we can define the two possible inverses of the mapping, corresponding to the positive and negative branches. We have
\begin{align} \zeta = g_+(z) \amp= \frac{1}{2}\left(z + \sqrt{z^2 - 4a}\right), \tag{4.6.8}\\ \zeta = g_-(z) \amp= \frac{1}{2}\left(z - \sqrt{z^2 - 4a}\right). \tag{4.6.9} \end{align}
Let us return to the perspective of images from the \(\zeta\)-plane to the \(z\)-plane. We can now consider the images of circles in the \(\zeta\)-plane that have either been horizontally shifted and/or vertically shifted. The two critical points (points where the map is not conformal) mentioned above correspond to either \(\zeta = \pm a\) or \(z = \pm 2a\text{.}\)
Firstly in Figure 4.6.10, we see that horizontal shifts of the circle will corresponding to shifting and deforming the ellipse such that, as a critical point is approached, this forms a point of non-conformality in the image (a cusp).
Joukowski map
Figure 4.6.10. We now consider shifting the circle with \(|\zeta| = 2\) to the left, so that the circumferance passes through the critical point at \(\zeta = a = 1\text{.}\) This produces an image that resembles an aerofoil with a sharp trailing edge.
Top-bottom asymmetry can also be introduced by considering vertical shifts of the preimages.
Joukowski map
Figure 4.6.11. Vertical shifts correspond to changing the top-bottom symmetry of the aerofoil. In this case, notice that if the circle in the left plane passes through a critical point, this produces a self-intersecting shape.